All posts

Dream & Improve

Kitchen or Bath Remodel? Answer These Questions First

They're the two most expensive rooms to redo, and you live with the result every day. Here's how to decide how far to go, and who to ask before you sign.

By Adam Fry-Pierce · 2 min read

Kitchens and bathrooms are the two renovations homeowners think hardest about before signing a contract. They're the most involved rooms in the house to redo, and you live with the result every single day. That's why these two deserve the most thought before anyone picks up a hammer.

Start with the problem, not the picture

What's actually wrong with the room? Write it down. A leak, failing grout, cabinets that won't close, too little counter space, a layout that doesn't work for how you cook. Or is it mostly that the room looks dated?

The list points to the job. A functional problem points to a repair or a targeted fix. A dated look points to cosmetic work. A layout that fights you every day is the case for moving walls and plumbing.

A refresh or a full remodel

Cosmetic updates (paint, cabinet fronts and hardware, counters, fixtures, lighting) change how a room feels with less disruption and a shorter timeline. A full remodel moves plumbing, wiring, and sometimes walls. It takes longer, it needs permits, and it often uncovers surprises once the walls are open.

Neither one is right in general. The right one is whichever fixes the problems on your list.

Check what's behind the walls first

Kitchens and baths are where the water is. Before you choose finishes, make sure the plumbing, venting, and subfloor are sound. A bathroom fan that vents into the attic, a slow drip under the sink, or soft flooring near the tub should be dealt with before new tile goes over it. New finishes over an old problem don't fix the problem. They hide it until it's bigger.

If you might sell in the next few years

Buyers compare your house with what else is for sale nearby, not with your receipts. So if selling is anywhere on your horizon, ask your agent before you commit. They can pull recent sales near you, show you what similar homes have in their kitchens and bathrooms, and tell you what buyers in your area are expecting. That answer is local and it changes, so ask for a fresh one.

Get real bids

Get written bids for the same scope from more than one contractor. Bids that differ a lot usually describe different jobs. Our guide to understanding contractor bids covers how to compare them, and how to vet a general contractor covers who to trust with the work.

Where Reyn fits in

If your agent set you up with Reyn, start with your home's plan. Anything your inspection flagged in the kitchen or bathroom shows up there, so it gets handled before new finishes go in. Then take the bigger question to your agent. Whether a remodel makes sense for your house and your market is a local call, and your agent knows your market.